refused,â she repeated. âWe can show you the security tapes if you want.â
Culligan shook his head. âMaybe in time.â Culligan never saw the prosecution team as enemies. Adversaries in the courtroom, sure, but at least in Braddock County, everyone pulled on the same oar in favor of justice. Even J. Daniel Petrelli, though his version of justice always came with a harsh spin and five exclamation points.
âWhen he confessed, did he tell you why he attacked the guy?â
âSome bullshit story about a kidnapping when he was eleven years old,â Hackner said.
Culliganâs head snapped up. âIâm sorry, how old did you say Ethan is?â
âTwenty-three.â
âI donât understand. Did the victimâwhatâs his name?â
âWe donât know,â Hackner said. âJohn Doe for now.â
âDid Mr. Doe just get out of prison or something? Was there a vendetta against him?â
âNot that we know of.â
Culligan put his pen down and shifted in his seat. âPlease donât be difficult. Why did Ethan allegedly kill a man twelve years after he was kidnapped?â
âThe suspect just had a birthday,â Hackner clarified. âSo, it was closer to eleven years ago, or so he claims. Thatâs the bullshit part. There never was a kidnapping.â
âHe made it up?â
âItâs not a complicated thing to look up kidnappings,â Hackner said. âHe gave us a date and a place, and we checked both local and federal records, and thereâs nothing there.â
âWhy would he make something like that up?â Culligan asked. It made no sense.
Hackner rolled his eyes. âMaybe when you look down at yourself and you see your hands and legs covered in someone elseâs blood, you feel the urge to make up a quick story. How the hell should I know?â
Culligan looked to Pam, whose eyes were somewhere other than the conversation. âIs that what my client told you at the time of his arrest?â he asked. âThat he was kidnapped?â If he didnât have as solid a relationship with Hackner as he did, the lieutenant might have taken offense at being second-guessed. As it was, Hackner looked away. âDetective Hastings?â
She scowled as she inhaled deeply through her nose. âThat is what he told me.â
âBut?â There seemed clearly to be more.
âIt was the way he told me,â she said. âHe seemed genuinely flabbergasted to be put under arrest. Like killing the John Doe was the most obvious thing in the world.â
Culligan scratched the back of his head. It seemed that every new answer deepened his sense of confusion. âWhat are you telling me?â he asked. âOr maybe what are you not telling me is the better question. Iâm kind of lost here.â
âIâm telling you that I believe him.â
Culligan looked to Hackner. âYou said no such kidnapping ever happened.â
âLet me restate it then,â Pam said. âI think that Ethan Falk really believes it happened.â
âJust as he might believe that heâs Santa Claus,â Hackner said. âBelieving doesnât make it true.â
Pam wouldnât back down. âYou asked.â
âBecause I need to know.â
âHe could be delusional, of course,â Pam said. She seemed to be arguing with herself. âThatâll take a shrink to figure out. But I saw the raw emotion in the heat of the moment, and Iâll bet everything that if you could climb into his head and look around, youâll see pictures that are scary as hell.â
Culligan looked over to Hackner, and then back to Pam. âOkay, then. Anything else I need to know?â
âNope,â Hackner said, and he stood. The meeting was over.
* * *
Ethan Falk did not look like a murderer. In Culliganâs experience, only sixty percent of criminals had the criminal
Cathy Cole
Chris T. Kat
Caridad Piñeiro
William Tyree
Jillian Stone
Tim Green
Terry Mancour
Anne Mather
Jenna Helland
Vivian Vande Velde